Cushman & Wakefield today released fourth quarter statistics for the Manhattan commercial
real estate market that show year-end leasing activity reached the highest total since 2000. On
the strength of the new leasing activity, which accounted for 30.1 million square feet, the
vacancy rate dropped to 9.1 percent, down from 10.5 percent a year ago.
With year-over-year leasing exceeding last year's total by more than 16 percent, the vacancy
rates in each of Manhattan's three submarkets remained three of the four tightest Central
Business Districts in the nation, with Midtown South leading the way with a 6.4 percent vacancy
rate. Manhattan is the largest CBD in the nation, with a total of 393 million square feet and
based on the space tracked by Cushman & Wakefield, it accounts for more than 25 percent of
all the CBD office space in the nation.
The strong leasing activity this year was driven by 51 transactions over 100,000 square
feet, which is the highest total since 2004.
The vacancy rate year-over-year for class-A office space decreased 1.4 percent to 9.6
percent. The class-B vacancy rate dropped the most at 1.5 percent year-over-year and ended the
year at 8.0 percent. The class-C vacancy rate decreased 1.1 percent and ended at 8.6
percent.
Overall average asking rents in Manhattan registered $57.23 per-square-foot at the end of
the year, up $2.89 per square foot or 5.3 percent from $54.34 a year ago and the highest asking
rent since August 2009. The largest increase in rents was recorded in the most expensive market
in the nation, the Midtown class-A market, where average asking rents reached $71.22 per square
foot, up 5.9 percent from a year ago.
Net absorption, which is the measure of the net change in occupied space over a given period
of time, was positive 5.2 million square feet. That total is the highest full year absorption
in Manhattan since 2005 and the first time since 2000 that all four quarters of the year
reported positive absorption.
"2011 has been a strong leasing year backed by the revival of Downtown and the World
Trade Center and the record number of large lease transactions around Manhattan," said
Joseph R. Harbert, Cushman & Wakefield's Chief Operating Officer for the New York Metro
Region.
The Downtown market, which saw the strongest leasing volume in more than a decade, ended the
year with a vacancy rate of 9.5 percent compared to 11.5 percent a year ago. The submarket saw
asking rents increase $1.10 per-square-foot to $39.88 per-square-foot from $38.78
per-square-foot. The class-A asking rents rose 3.9 percent to $43.36 from $42.68 a year
ago.
Downtown had two major leases at the new World Trade Center. Conde Nast leased 1.0 million
square feet at One World Trade Center and the City of New York leased 600,000 square feet at
Four World Trade Center. In addition, MSCI, Inc. and Wilmer Cutler Pickering leased a total of
more than 336,000 square feet at Seven World Trade Center, which is now fully leased.
The market with the fastest asking rent growth was the Midtown South class-A market, where
the vacancy rate stood at 4.6 percent at the end of 2011 and the asking rents increased 14.6
percent from a year ago. The class-A asking rent at year-end was $57.44 from $50.13 a year
ago.
The Midtown market, which ended the year with a 9.6 percent vacancy, down 1.0 percent from
10.6 percent a year ago, saw an increase in class-A asking rent of 5.9 percent to $71.22 from
$67.27 a year ago.
Following a strong 2011, Cushman & Wakefield pointed to remaining uncertainty in the
global economy that could slow activity, but noted recent employment growth and the strength of
the local technology sector as positives for 2012.
"The outlook is clouded and new leasing activity is unlikely to approach the strong
levels of 2011. That being said, a positive we can look to is a technology sector that is
rapidly growing and continuing to hire," said Ken McCarthy, senior economist and senior
managing director at Cushman & Wakefield.
By industry, financial services accounted for 29.7 percent of all leasing by year-end,
followed by information/media at 25.3 percent, government, education and social services at 9.9
percent and apparel at 9.0 percent.
INVESTMENT SALES
The volume of property sales closed in 2011 in Manhattan is the third highest total on record,
exceeded only by 2006 and 2007. By year-end, $25.8 billion in sales were completed, with $3.1
billion currently under contract, compared to $13.7 billion closed in 2010. This represents an
increase of 88 percent.
The second half of 2011 had a total of $12.7 billion in sales recorded on top of the first
six months of the year that totaled $13.1 billion. The highest volume on record in Manhattan
occurred in 2007, when the total hit $47.8 billion.
Class-A office space has accounted for more than $9.4 billion or 37 percent of the total
property sales in 2011, followed by other office space at more than $3.8 billion, hotel
property at more than $3.6 billion, land/development at nearly $3.6 billion and multifamily at
nearly $3.4 billion. Hotel and multifamily properties had the largest year-over-year percentage
increases in sales, with 158 percent for hotel and 145 percent for multifamily.
Institutional investors led the way in total acquisitions this year, accounting for 36
percent of total sales, followed by real estate investment trusts (REITs) at 26 percent,
private capital at 26 percent, and foreign investors at 9 percent. In 2010, private capital led
the way with 35 percent, followed by REITs at 21 percent and institutional investors at 15
percent.
A significant component of the increase in Capital Markets activity year-over-year was a
surge in recapitalizations, which accounted for $9.1 billion or 35 percent of the total sales,
compared with 19 percent in 2010.
Significant property sale transactions this year included the recapitalization of 1633
Broadway, a 2.5 million-square-foot class-A office tower. Paramount Group Inc. recapitalized a
49 percent interest in the property. Cushman & Wakefield Sonnenblick Goldman arranged the
transaction. Also, 601 West 26th Street, a 2.3 million-square-foot tower was purchased by RXR
Realty LLC.
RETAIL
The Manhattan retail market performed strongly through the end of 2011. Both the Upper and
Lower Fifth Avenue corridors saw significant asking rental rate increases from last
quarter.
Upper Fifth Avenue, from the north side of 49th Street to 60th Street, had a fourth quarter
average ground floor asking rent of $2,338 per square foot, a 12.7 percent increase from last
quarter. The Lower Fifth Avenue market, from 42nd Street to the south side of 49th Street,
continued to see increased demand and strong pedestrian foot traffic. Luxury brands have been
active in this corridor, including Ted Baker, which leased 12,000 square feet at the corner of
Fifth Avenue and 48th Street. Asking rents in the Lower Fifth Avenue corridor increased 50
percent since the third quarter, to a record $865 per square foot.
Times Square also reported a significant increase in asking rents, up 15 percent to $968 per
square foot. Contributing to this increase was a lease of a below market piece of space that
had been on the market for a long time, by SuperDry, a men's and women's apparel store. Asking
rents in the "Bowtie," from 42nd to 47th Street on Broadway and Seventh Avenue,
continued to exceed asking rents in the Times Square market, and are currently at $1,521 per
square foot.
In the traditionally strong SoHo market, which stretches from West Houston to Grand Streets
and West Broadway to Broadway, asking rents slightly decreased in the fourth quarter to $288
per square foot, however asking rents on the prime streets like Prince, Spring and Broadway
exceeded $500-$600 per square foot.
The Madison Avenue submarket, which stretches from 56th Street to 72nd Street, has seen a
fundamental strengthening in 2011, as availability decreased 0.5 percentage points to 11.7
percent this quarter and asking rents increased to $908 per square foot, up 13.6 percent over
the prior quarter.
The Third Avenue and Upper West Side submarkets showed strong fundamentals, with a slight
decrease in asking rents from last quarter due to higher priced space being leased during the
quarter.
* * *